Monin

Awarded a 3/5 green leaf rating, the Monin Natural Zero Pumpkin Spice is a middle-of-the-road choice for consumers searching for cleaner food alternatives. This product offers a blend that caters to those looking to avoid traditional sugars and caloric sweeteners, opting instead for zero-calorie sweeteners like erythritol and stevia.

The absence of organic certification leads to a reduction in its green leaf score, reflecting the product’s use of ingredients that may not align with the highest standards of environmental sustainability. Further, the lack of a non-GMO verification suggests the potential inclusion of genetically modified components, which could be a drawback for those prioritizing non-GMO foods.

The product does incorporate certain ingredients that are flagged as concerns. The inclusion of added sweeteners, erythritol and stevia, although not traditional sugars, still results in a penalty due to the scoring system’s stance on any added sweeteners. Additionally, components such as ‘natural flavors’ and xanthan gum contribute to the deduction of points. ‘Natural flavors’ is a broad term that could encompass a variety of sources, and while xanthan gum is commonly used as a thickener and stabilizer in food products, its presence is less desirable within the parameters of this evaluation.

Despite these issues, the Monin Natural Zero Pumpkin Spice does not contain any explicitly harmful chemicals or preservatives, which could be seen as a positive aspect for those seeking cleaner food products. The use of water as the primary ingredient and the incorporation of sea salt and lactic acid, both recognized for their natural origins, help balance the overall profile of the product.

The Monin Natural Zero Pumpkin Spice embodies a compromise within the health-conscious market. It steers clear of traditional sugars and artificial preservatives, yet it doesn’t fully embrace the ideals of organic and non-GMO standards. This product fits a niche for those looking for a moderate option that leans towards a cleaner ingredient list but doesn’t fully commit to the highest levels of clean eating.