Breyers

Breyers CarbSmart™ Chocolate receives a 1/5 green leaf rating, reflecting a product that does not align with the healthier food options our website advocates. This ice cream alternative is not organic, includes GMO ingredients, and contains multiple added sweeteners and additives that are flagged for their potential negative health impacts.

The product’s ingredient list features non-organic milk and cream, which contributes to the initial deductions in its score. The presence of GMO ingredients further diminishes its standing. Sweeteners such as sorbitol, acesulfame potassium, and sucralose are particularly concerning due to their artificial nature and potential health risks, leading to a substantial reduction in points. These sweeteners are often used in “low-carb” or “sugar-free” products, but their inclusion does not necessarily equate to a healthier product.

Additional additives, including natural flavor, mono and diglycerides, and glycerin, are commonly found in processed foods but are not ideal for those seeking cleaner, simpler food options. The product also contains maltodextrin, which is singled out for its known adverse health effects, especially on blood sugar levels and the gut microbiome.

The use of vegetable gums such as guar and carob bean, although less concerning, are still processed ingredients that some individuals may wish to avoid. The presence of Dutched cocoa, processed with alkali, also contributes to the product’s overall score, as this process can alter the natural properties of cocoa.

Breyers CarbSmart™ Chocolate is rated at the lowest end of our scale. This evaluation is rooted in a commitment to transparency about ingredients that may not support a clean eating lifestyle. Consumers looking for cleaner, more natural food products may prefer to consider alternatives that score higher on the green leaf rating scale, featuring fewer processed ingredients and no artificial sweeteners or GMOs.